Within Haunted Orkney
How Do Orkney's House Ghosts Survive?
Kirkwall, Tankerness House and local white-lady and black-lady tales show how Orkney's hauntings cling to homes, museums and parishes.
On this page
- Tankerness House and museum footsteps
- White ladies, black ladies and family memory
- Tours, storytellers and public dark history
Page outline Jump by section
Introduction
Kirkwall’s house ghosts are quieter than Orkney’s famous coastal legends, but they are central to the islands’ haunted character. In and around the town, the stories tend to settle in former homes, museums, parish houses and family estates: footsteps in Tankerness House, the servant-girl tragedy attached to Berstane House, the White Lady of Clestrain, and black-lady traditions remembered in inland Orkney rather than on the shore. Their value is not that they prove apparitions exist, but that they show how Orcadian ghost stories survive through rooms, family memory, guides, local historians and storytellers. Tankerness House, now the Orkney Museum, is the best Kirkwall anchor because its public rooms still carry the feeling of a private household, while the wider parish stories show how domestic haunting in Orkney often turns on grief, secrecy, class, colonial contact and the afterlife of old lairdly houses.[orkneymuseums.co.uk]orkneymuseums.co.ukOrkney Council Museums The Orkney MuseumOrkney Council Museums The Orkney Museum
Why Kirkwall’s House Ghosts Feel Different
Kirkwall is not a “haunted city” in the theatrical sense of a place selling one dominant phantom. Its dark history is more domestic and civic. The centre of town is built around St Magnus Cathedral, Broad Street, old mercantile houses, former ecclesiastical property and narrow lanes where witchcraft, piracy, death, family status and folklore can be folded into a short walk. Modern visitor listings for “The Dark Side of Kirkwall” describe a ghost tour of old Kirkwall beginning near the Cathedral, moving through streets and lanes, and ending with Georgian-style storytelling in a historic home; that format is revealing, because the ghost story is presented not as an isolated scare, but as part of town history, food, performance and household atmosphere.[Orkney.com]orkney.comThe Dark Side of Kirkwall | Orkney.comThe Dark Side of Kirkwall | Orkney.com
That domestic emphasis also keeps the stories within human scale. Orkney’s better-known supernatural landscape includes trows, selkies, sea-monsters, witchcraft memories and dangerous coasts, but Kirkwall’s house legends ask smaller, sharper questions: who lived in this room, who served here, what did the family remember, and why did a sound on the stairs become a story? Orcadian storyteller Tom Muir’s work is important here because he is both a traditional storyteller and a museum-linked interpreter of Orkney’s folklore; TRACS describes him as telling stories of ghosts, witches, shipwrecks and “humorous goings on”, while NorthLink’s account of the Orkney Folklore Trail shows how local storytelling has been adapted for visitors without stripping it from place.[TRACS]tracscotland.orgTRACSTom MuirTRACSTom Muir
The result is a haunted geography that is less about remote ruins than about inhabited memory. A house may become a museum, a family room may become a display, a servant’s story may become a warning, and a parish tale may be kept alive by a storyteller rather than by a plaque. That is why this page keeps close to Kirkwall and domestic ghost stories beyond the shore, rather than retelling Orkney’s wider coastal folklore.
Tankerness House and Museum Footsteps
Tankerness House is the strongest Kirkwall example because it is both a documented historic building and a reported haunted setting. The Orkney Museum states that the museum “used to be a house” and that Tankerness House was home to the Baikie family of Tankerness for three centuries; its north and south wings had earlier been manses for Cathedral clergy, and the arched gateway was built in 1574 by Gilbert Foulzie, the first Protestant minister. The building opened as a museum in 1968 and is now an A-listed structure, with the Baikie Library and Drawing Room used to show visitors how the house looked as a family home.[Orkney Council Museums]orkneymuseums.co.ukOrkney Council Museums The Orkney MuseumOrkney Council Museums The Orkney Museum
The haunting attached to it is modest but memorable: ghostly footsteps, reportedly heard in the Orkney Museum, often around lunchtime. The account is not presented in the official museum page as a verified phenomenon; it appears in a reflective “Paranormal & Society” discussion of ghost stories as heritage interpretation. What makes it useful is the way the writer frames the story: hearing about footsteps in the museum made the former domestic life of Tankerness House feel suddenly present, adding “layers” to a building that visitors might otherwise treat only as a display space.[Paranormal & Society]paranormalandsociety.wordpress.comOpen source on wordpress.com.
That is exactly how a house ghost often works in Orkney. It does not need a spectacular apparition to be locally effective. A repeated sound in an old house — especially one whose corridors, stairs, library and drawing room still speak of former residents — becomes a way of imagining the building before it was civic property. The museum’s own history reinforces that reading: Tankerness House was sold to Kirkwall Burgh Council in 1951, split into flats, nearly lost to demolition and car-park proposals, and then preserved as a museum that opened in 1968. The ghostly footsteps therefore sit on top of a real story of domestic use, decline, public rescue and reinvention.[Orkney Council Museums]orkneymuseums.co.ukOrkney Council Museums The Tankerness House Story | Orkney MuseumsOrkney Council Museums The Tankerness House Story | Orkney Museums
There is also an archaeological depth beneath the house that suits Kirkwall’s layered atmosphere. Historic Environment Scotland’s Trove record identifies Tankerness House Museum at 35, 37 and 39 Broad Street as a house with 15th-century classification and later museum use. Notes on the site record 17th- to 19th-century floors overlaying 13th- to 14th-century material, with references to earlier waterfront or reclamation activity in the area. That does not “explain” footsteps, but it does show why the building feels like a stack of different Kirkwalls rather than a single preserved moment.[Trove Scot]trove.scotOpen source on trove.scot.
White Ladies, Black Ladies and Family Memory
Orkney’s domestic ghost stories often use familiar Scottish ghost-story colours — white ladies, black ladies, shadowy women on stairs or in rooms — but their local meanings depend on the house and the family. The White Lady of Clestrain is a good example. The Hall of Clestrain, in Orphir, lies outside Kirkwall but belongs to the same domestic tradition: a lairdly house, a remembered family, a story of fear and explanation. Orkney.com identifies the Hall as the birthplace of Arctic explorer John Rae, built in 1769 and originally home to Patrick Honeyman of Graemsay; John Rae junior was born there on 30 September 1813.[Orkney.com]orkney.comHall of ClestrainHall of Clestrain
The ghost tradition belongs especially to the older Ha’ Hoose of Clestrain, near the later Hall. Orkneyology’s account describes the Old Ha’ as a former house, probably 17th-century in origin, associated with the 1725 raid by the pirate John Gow and later with the White Lady of Clestrain. In that same telling, the young John Rae was frightened by lights seen in the old building at night and thought they were ghostly, while the practical explanation given is that smugglers were using lights to signal that the coast was clear.[Orkneyology.com]orkneyology.comJohn Rae, Little-Known Arctic ExplorerJohn Rae, Little-Known Arctic Explorer
That combination is important. The White Lady is not simply a free-floating apparition; she is attached to a house with family drama, pirate memory, childhood fear and a rational counter-reading. The source tradition itself allows scepticism into the story. Rather than spoiling the haunting, the smuggler explanation makes it more Orcadian: the same building can hold a ghost tale, a criminal episode, a family memory and a practical island explanation at once.[Orkneyology.com]orkneyology.comJohn Rae, Little-Known Arctic ExplorerJohn Rae, Little-Known Arctic Explorer
Black-lady traditions work differently, and they require more caution. The Black Lady of Nisthouse in Harray is often summarised as the ghost of a woman brought back from the African Gold Coast by Joseph Clouston and buried in Orkney; About Orkney preserves this tradition in a Halloween ghost-story roundup. The details are brief in accessible online sources, but even in summary the story is striking because it links an inland Orkney house legend to empire, race, household status and the unsettling afterlife of a woman remembered more as a spectral figure than as a fully documented person.[About Orkney]aboutorkney.comghost stories and halloweenghost stories and halloween
That makes the Black Lady of Nisthouse a different kind of house ghost from the White Lady of Clestrain. The Clestrain story is mediated through a named Orcadian storyteller and linked to a famous local explorer’s childhood memories; the Nisthouse story, as publicly available online, is thinner and more morally uneasy. It should not be inflated into certainty. Its significance is that Orkney’s domestic hauntings do not only preserve cosy family lore. Sometimes they also preserve fragments of unequal households, overseas contact and stories in which the person at the centre of the legend may have had little control over how she was remembered.
Berstane House and the Tragedy Behind a Domestic Haunting
The ghost of Berstane House brings the domestic pattern closer to Kirkwall itself. The Ísmús folklore archive records the tale as “The Ghost of Berstane House” and summarises it as the story of a servant girl at Berstane House, Kirkwall, who became pregnant; her ghost is said to haunt the house searching for her child. The archive links the item to Tom Muir’s Orkney Folk Tales, giving the story a traceable modern folklore source rather than leaving it as an anonymous internet rumour.[Ísmús]ismus.isÍsmús The Ghost of Berstane HouseÍsmús The Ghost of Berstane House
This is one of the most revealing house-ghost patterns in the Orkney material. The haunting is not centred on a laird or a battlefield death, but on a servant girl, pregnancy, secrecy and loss. In a small community, such a story would have carried social weight: reputation, illegitimacy, domestic service, childbirth and shame all belonged to household life, not to the open coast. The ghost searching for a child is therefore less a monster story than a compressed social tragedy.
It also shows why the word “domestic” matters. A grand house may look solid and respectable from the outside, but the haunting tradition asks readers to imagine what happened inside: who slept under the roof, who was vulnerable, who could speak openly, and whose pain was later converted into a ghost story. That does not mean the events can be verified from the brief online summary alone. It means the legend preserves the emotional shape of a real social fear, even if the surviving account is folkloric rather than evidential in the legal or historical sense.[Ísmús]ismus.isÍsmús The Ghost of Berstane HouseÍsmús The Ghost of Berstane House
Tours, Storytellers and Public Dark History
Kirkwall’s public dark history now sits somewhere between commemoration, tourism and storytelling. The witchcraft-trials material is the clearest example of the ethical shift. Orkney.com describes a Kirkwall walking tour led by Dr Ragnhild Ljosland that explored the historical witchcraft trials, noting that more than 70 people were taken to court in Orkney between the late 16th and early 18th centuries. Orkney Heritage Society’s memorial page is more formal, explaining that the Gallow Ha memorial at the top of Clay Loan commemorates victims of the Orkney witch trials and that Ernest Marwick estimated around 70 accused, while the University of Edinburgh’s Survey of Scottish Witchcraft found 72.[Orkney.com]orkney.comWalking in the footsteps of Orkney's witches | Orkney.comWalking in the footsteps of Orkney's witches | Orkney.com
This matters for house ghosts because Kirkwall’s dark storytelling cannot be treated as mere entertainment. The same town that offers ghost walks also contains places where accused people were tried, imprisoned, executed, remembered and reinterpreted. A responsible haunted-history page should therefore distinguish between folklore apparitions, such as the White Lady of Clestrain, and documented persecution, such as the witchcraft trials. Both may appear on “dark” walks, but they do not carry the same evidential or moral status.[Orkney.com]orkney.comWalking in the footsteps of Orkney's witches | Orkney.comWalking in the footsteps of Orkney's witches | Orkney.com
Modern tours also show how Orkney’s ghost stories are kept alive in performance. “The Dark Side of Kirkwall” describes a route through atmospheric streets and lanes, stories of Orcadian ghosts and witches, and a candlelit Georgian supper in a historic home. That is not an archive in the strict sense, but it is a form of public transmission. It turns private rooms and old lanes into a shared storytelling space, while making clear that what is being offered is a guided experience, not proof of the supernatural.[Orkney.com]orkney.comThe Dark Side of Kirkwall | Orkney.comThe Dark Side of Kirkwall | Orkney.com
The Orkney Folklore Trail offers a related but broader model. NorthLink’s interview with Tom and Rhonda Muir explains that the trail was designed to unlock stories at locations and to make landscapes more meaningful; Robert Gordon University’s case study also notes that intellectual-property agreements were needed because Muir had collected, developed and published folklore stories for many years and his voice featured in the app. That is a useful reminder that ghost stories are cultural work. They are selected, told, adapted, owned, credited and sometimes commercialised.[NorthLink Ferries]northlinkferries.co.ukNorth Link Ferries The Orkney Folklore Trail | North Link FerriesNorth Link Ferries The Orkney Folklore Trail | North Link Ferries
How Credible Are These Stories?
The strongest answer is mixed. Tankerness House is historically well documented, and the museum’s former domestic use is secure, but the footsteps remain an anecdotal haunting rather than an independently verified event. Berstane House has a traceable folklore entry, but the publicly accessible summary is short. The White Lady of Clestrain is preserved through named storytelling and attached to known places and families, but its most interesting feature is that the tradition itself includes a non-ghostly explanation for lights in the old house. The Black Lady of Nisthouse is memorable, but online evidence for the details is thin and should be handled as local legend rather than settled history.[orkneymuseums.co.uk]orkneymuseums.co.ukOrkney Council Museums The Orkney MuseumOrkney Council Museums The Orkney Museum
A good way to read these stories is to separate four layers. First is the building: Tankerness House, Berstane House, Clestrain, Nisthouse and other homes can often be placed in real geography. Second is the social memory: family, servants, lairds, travellers, accused witches and parish communities. Third is the reported phenomenon: footsteps, lights, apparitions or a ghost searching for a child. Fourth is the later retelling: museum interpretation, folklore books, walking tours, apps, blogs and local tourism pages. The more layers that can be checked independently, the sturdier the account becomes as local history; the fewer that can be checked, the more carefully it should be treated as folklore.
That careful reading does not make the stories less interesting. In fact, it makes them more revealing. Orkney’s domestic ghosts survive because they do a job that plain building history cannot always do. They make readers imagine rooms after closing time, footsteps in a former family house, a frightened child passing an old ha’, a servant girl erased by shame, or an inland parish remembering an outsider through a troubling spectral label. The haunting is therefore not only in the claim that something was seen or heard. It is in the way a house keeps asking to be interpreted.
What These House Legends Add to Orkney’s Haunted Map
Kirkwall and the inland house stories widen Orkney’s haunted map beyond cliffs, mounds and sea-roads. They show that the county’s supernatural imagination is not only maritime. It is also domestic: built into town houses, former manses, drawing rooms, old halls, servants’ quarters, parish estates and public museums. Tankerness House turns a museum visit into an encounter with former household life; Berstane House keeps a servant’s tragedy in circulation; Clestrain folds a white-lady tale into piracy, smuggling and John Rae memory; Nisthouse hints at the difficult afterlife of empire and household inequality in local legend.[orkneymuseums.co.uk]orkneymuseums.co.ukOrkney Council Museums The Orkney MuseumOrkney Council Museums The Orkney Museum
For visitors, the practical lesson is simple: Orkney’s ghost stories are best approached through place and provenance. Ask where the story is located, whether the building is public or private, who preserved the tale, and whether it is backed by archive, museum interpretation, named folklore collection, tour tradition or only repeated hearsay. Kirkwall’s house ghosts are at their most compelling when treated neither as proven hauntings nor as disposable spooky content, but as fragile local stories that reveal how Orcadians have remembered homes, grief, status and strange sounds in old rooms.
Amazon book picks
Further Reading
Books and field guides related to How Do Orkney's House Ghosts Survive?. Use these as the next step if you want deeper reading beyond the article.
The folklore of Orkney and Shetland
First published 1975. Subjects: Social life and customs, Folklore, United Kingdom, Great Britain, Customs & Traditions, Sociology.
Scottish Ghost Stories
First published 1911. Subjects: Folklore, Ghosts, Scottish Ghost stories.
Orkney Folklore and Sea Legends
Includes Orcadian legends associated with places and people.
The Mammoth Book of Scottish Ghost Stories
Supports readers exploring haunted historic houses.
eBay marketplace picks
Marketplace Samples
Live-tested eBay searches with available results related to this page.
Endnotes
1.
Source: orkney.com
Title: The Dark Side of Kirkwall | Orkney.com
Link:https://www.orkney.com/events/the-dark-side-of-kirkwall
2.
Source: tracscotland.org
Title: TRACSTom Muir
Link:https://tracscotland.org/storytellers/tom-muir/
3.
Source: trove.scot
Link:https://www.trove.scot/place/2531
4.
Source: orkney.com
Title: Hall of Clestrain
Link:https://www.orkney.com/listings/hall-of-clestrain
5.
Source: orkneyology.com
Title: John Rae, Little-Known Arctic Explorer
Link:https://www.orkneyology.com/john-rae.html
6.
Source: orkneyology.com
Link:https://www.orkneyology.com/tales-from-tom.html
7.
Source: orkney.com
Title: Walking in the footsteps of Orkney’s witches | Orkney.com
Link:https://www.orkney.com/news/witchcraft-trials-walk
8.
Source: orkneyology.com
Title: Orkney Folklore Trail
Link:https://www.orkneyology.com/orkney-folklore-trail.html
9.
Source: orkney.com
Link:https://www.orkney.com/listings/the-orkney-museum
10.
Source: archive.org
Link:https://archive.org/stream/in.ernet.dli.2015.69840/2015.69840.Proceedings-Of-The-Society-Of-Antiquaries-Of-Scotland-1937-1938-Vol72_djvu.txt
11.
Source: orkneymuseums.co.uk
Title: Orkney Council Museums The Orkney Museum
Link:https://orkneymuseums.co.uk/our-museums/the-orkney-museum/
12.
Source: paranormalandsociety.wordpress.com
Link:https://paranormalandsociety.wordpress.com/2018/03/17/orkney-stepping-back-in-time-with-ghosts/
13.
Source: ismus.is
Title: Ísmús The Ghost of Berstane House
Link:https://www.ismus.is/tjodfraedi/sagnir/18443
14.
Source: northlinkferries.co.uk
Title: North Link Ferries The Orkney Folklore Trail | North Link Ferries
Link:https://www.northlinkferries.co.uk/orkney-blog/orkney-folklore-trail/
15.
Source: orkneymuseums.co.uk
Title: Orkney Council Museums The Tankerness House Story | Orkney Museums
Link:https://orkneymuseums.co.uk/the-tankerness-house-story/
16.
Source: aboutorkney.com
Title: ghost stories and halloween
Link:https://www.aboutorkney.com/2019/10/31/ghost-stories-and-halloween/
17.
Source: Wikipedia
Title: Hall of Clestrain
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hall_of_Clestrain
18.
Source: northlinkferries.co.uk
Link:https://www.northlinkferries.co.uk/orkney-blog/great-museums-in-orkney/
19.
Source: northlinkferries.co.uk
Link:https://www.northlinkferries.co.uk/orkney-blog/ten-orkney-hidden-gems/
20.
Source: ismus.is
Link:https://ismus.is/tjodfraedi/sagnir/18588
21.
Source: ismus.is
Link:https://www.ismus.is/tjodfraedi/sagnir/16601
22.
Source: ismus.is
Link:https://www.ismus.is/tjodfraedi/sagnir/17786
23.
Source: ismus.is
Link:https://www.ismus.is/stadir/29995
24.
Source: ismus.is
Link:https://www.ismus.is/tjodfraedi/sagnir/17765
25.
Source: ismus.is
Link:https://www.ismus.is/tjodfraedi/sagnir_aevintyri/18446/
26.
Source: ismus.is
Link:https://www.ismus.is/tjodfraedi/sagnir/17779
27.
Source: ismus.is
Title: sagnir aevintyri
Link:https://www.ismus.is/tjodfraedi/sagnir_aevintyri/?flokkur=32&sida=596
28.
Source: ismus.is
Link:https://www.ismus.is/tjodfraedi/sagnir/18360/
29.
Source: youtube.com
Title: Hall of Clestrain
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NjOwTscZFkc
Additional References
30.
Source: youtube.com
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H86EuNi2vCM
Source snippet
Kirkwall Orkney history folklore The Fin Folk of the Orkney Islands | Celtic Folklore and Mythology Story Crow...
31.
Source: orkneyheritagesociety.org.uk
Title: orkney witchcraft trial memorial
Link:https://orkneyheritagesociety.org.uk/projects/orkney-witchcraft-trial-memorial/
Source snippet
Orkney Witchcraft Trials Memorial | Orkney Heritage Society...
32.
Source: youtube.com
Title: Orkney Folktales in the Landscape
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rThdeisiuck
Source snippet
A Day in Kirkwall, Orkney Islands: Historic Landmarks and the Finest Whisky Tasting...
33.
Source: youtube.com
Title: 6 The Orkney Witch Trials
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Raj-2zNLYs
Source snippet
Orkneyology Podcast (season 1, episode 1) "Ower wi' the moon" ~ Mulled wine and introductions...
34.
Source: youtube.com
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yqrF9j6r7Wo
Source snippet
Orkney Folktales in the Landscape...
35.
Source: visitscotland.com
Link:https://www.visitscotland.com/nl-nl/things-to-do/attractions/castles/haunted
36.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/www.foinhaven.co.uk/
37.
Source: artuk.org
Link:https://artuk.org/discover/artworks/gallow-ha-witchcraft-trials-memorial-346113
38.
Source: spookyencounters.co.uk
Link:https://spookyencounters.co.uk/ghost-hunts-by-venue/
39.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/groups/145317616194450/posts/152720405454171/
Topic Tree