Where Does Rutland Hide Its Ghosts?
Rutland’s haunted history is quieter than that of counties famous for ruined abbeys, plague pits or theatrical ghost tours, but that is part of its character.
Page outline Jump by section
Where Rutland’s ghost stories sit on the map
For this project, Rutland should be treated as the historic county: a small inland shire in the East Midlands, bordered by Leicestershire, Lincolnshire and Northamptonshire. The Wikishire historic-county map presents Rutland as a distinct historic county, and the county’s modern identity broadly follows the same compact geography, even though local government has changed over time.[Wikimedia Commons]commons.wikimedia.orgFile:England Historic Counties Rutland map.svgFile:England Historic Counties Rutland map.svg
That administrative history matters because some modern listings blur Rutland with neighbouring Leicestershire. Ashwell Prison ghost-hunt pages, for example, sometimes describe the site as “Oakham, Leicestershire”, even though the former prison is in Rutland near Ashwell and Burley. The confusion is not just a web-listing mistake: Rutland was absorbed into Leicestershire for local-government purposes in 1974 and regained unitary and ceremonial county status in 1997, so older or casual references can pull it westwards into Leicestershire’s orbit.[Wikipedia]WikipediaOpen source on wikipedia.org.
For haunted-history readers, the practical rule is simple: keep the centre of gravity on Rutland places and Rutland traditions, while recognising that stories, newspapers, tourism listings and ghost-hunt companies often use regional labels loosely. That is especially important for Ashwell, Oakham, Exton, Langham and the villages around Rutland Water, where the local setting is part of the atmosphere.
The best-known Rutland hauntings are scattered, not centralised
Rutland does not have a single Tower-of-London-style ghost story that dominates public imagination. Instead, its haunted map is made of brief, stubbornly local entries: an inn here, a rectory there, a former prison, a church, a hall, a village house. The long-running Paranormal Database lists eight Rutland entries, including Belmesthorpe’s Blue Bell Inn, an Edith Weston poltergeist report, Exton Hall’s Mistletoe Bough legend, North Luffenham Hall, Oakham School, a former rectory at Pilton, Stoke Dry church and Stocken Hall Farm at Stretton.[Paranormal Database]paranormaldatabase.comParanormal Database The Paranormal DatabaseParanormal Database The Paranormal Database
That source is useful as a catalogue, but it should be read carefully. Some entries are clearly labelled as legends, some are based on “historical record”, and others are late retellings of older motifs. In other words, Rutland’s ghost material is best approached as folklore and reported experience, not as confirmed paranormal evidence. The county’s eerie value lies in how these stories preserve local fears: the abandoned room, the locked chest, the guilty household, the isolated church, the watched window, the prison corridor after closure.
A few places stand out because they answer the questions readers usually bring to a haunted county page: where is the story, what is meant to appear, how old is the account, and how much independent support does it have?
Exton Hall and the bride in the chest
Exton Hall’s best-known supernatural association is not a simple apparition but a travelling legend: the Mistletoe Bough. The tale tells of a bride who, during wedding celebrations, hides in a chest during a game of hide-and-seek, becomes trapped, and is discovered years later as a skeleton in bridal dress. Rutland Heritage and Arts notes that Exton Old Hall is one of several historic homes linked to the tragic tale, while the Paranormal Database records Exton Hall as one of the supposed sites of the legend.[Rutland Heritage and Arts]rutlandheritageandarts.wordpress.comRutland Heritage and Arts ExtonRutland Heritage and Arts Exton[Paranormal Database]paranormaldatabase.comParanormal Database The Paranormal DatabaseParanormal Database The Paranormal Database
The key word is “one”. The Mistletoe Bough is claimed by several English houses, not just Exton. Its literary history is also unusually clear for a ghostly legend: it appeared in print as Samuel Rogers’s poem “Ginevra” in the 1820s and gained wider popularity through the 1830s song “The Mistletoe Bough”, after which it became a Christmas-season tale attached to old houses and locked chests.[Wikipedia]WikipediaLegend of the Mistletoe BoughLegend of the Mistletoe Bough
That makes Exton’s version valuable, but not because it proves a local tragedy. It shows how Rutland participated in a wider Victorian and post-Victorian folklore habit: attaching a portable horror story to a real country house. The appeal is obvious. Exton supplies the right ingredients — aristocratic setting, old hall, hidden spaces, marriage, disappearance and delayed discovery — even if the story’s documentary footing is much weaker than its atmosphere.
Langham House: a ghost story with its own sceptical ending
One of Rutland’s most interesting ghost accounts survives because it includes doubt inside the story itself. “A Ghost at Langham”, printed from The Rutland Magazine and County Historical Record, Volume 3, 1907/8, describes a remembered incident at Langham House: two people returning along the drive saw a ghostly figure near a flower bed, then entered the house and found a dying woman upstairs, convinced that a spiritual being had come for her.[langhaminrutland.org.uk]langhaminrutland.org.uklangham ghostlangham ghost
The account is atmospheric in the classic country-house manner: night journey, laurel hedge, alarmed witnesses, sickroom, delirium and an apparent omen of death. Yet its narrator does not simply endorse the haunting. The writer says he sees “no connection” between the sickroom scene and the figure in the garden, considers coincidence more likely, and even suggests a possible human explanation: someone with a grudge may have dressed up and hidden behind shrubs to frighten the returning pair.[langhaminrutland.org.uk]langhaminrutland.org.uklangham ghostlangham ghost
That sceptical turn is what makes the Langham case unusually useful. It preserves the emotional force of a ghost sighting while also showing how Edwardian local-history writing could contain rational explanation, social gossip and moral reflection in the same piece. The writer even notes that Langham House had since been rebuilt, the original garden altered and the supposed ghost “laid”, which quietly relocates the haunting from physical place to remembered story.[langhaminrutland.org.uk]langhaminrutland.org.uklangham ghostlangham ghost
Edith Weston, Belmesthorpe and the small reports that feel closest to folklore
Some Rutland entries are brief but evocative. At Edith Weston, a house was reportedly troubled by loud knocks in December 1896; the Paranormal Database summarises newspaper claims that people of different social ranks investigated without finding an explanation, including an incident where knocking seemed to come from a freshly varnished door without leaving marks.[Paranormal Database]paranormaldatabase.comParanormal Database The Paranormal DatabaseParanormal Database The Paranormal Database
That is the kind of small domestic case that belongs to the wider Victorian and late-Victorian poltergeist tradition. The details are not grand — knocks, doors, inspection, no visible cause — but they are exactly the kind of details that made newspaper ghost stories travel. The report also shows why caution is needed: without the original newspaper text and follow-up investigation, it is impossible to know whether the episode was a prank, building noise, misreporting, social excitement or something witnesses genuinely found baffling.
Belmesthorpe’s Blue Bell Inn has a more folkloric texture. The recorded story describes a hunched figure gliding towards a well, with a local tradition that the inn stands on the site of an old monastery and that incense is sometimes smelt.[Paranormal Database]paranormaldatabase.comParanormal Database The Paranormal DatabaseParanormal Database The Paranormal Database The elements are almost too perfect: an old inn, a religious backstory, a well, a scent associated with worship, and a moving figure. Whether or not any one sighting can be traced, the story expresses a familiar English haunted-inn pattern: hospitality layered over a possibly older sacred or communal site.
Ashwell Prison and the modern ghost-hunt economy
Ashwell Prison is Rutland’s most obvious modern paranormal-tourism location. The former HMP Ashwell was a Category C men’s prison in the parish of Burley, near Ashwell; it closed in 2011, Rutland County Council acquired it from the Ministry of Justice in 2013, and the site was redeveloped as Oakham Enterprise Park, with some original buildings and fencing remaining.[Inside Time]insidetime.orgInside Time Behind the Gate: HMP Ashwell – Abandoned – Inside TimeInside Time Behind the Gate: HMP Ashwell – Abandoned – Inside Time
The prison’s documented history is dramatic enough without ghosts. It began on the site of a Second World War US Army base, opened as an open prison in 1955, later became a Category C establishment, and suffered a major riot in April 2009 that left large parts of the prison uninhabitable before its eventual closure.[Inside Time]insidetime.orgInside Time Behind the Gate: HMP Ashwell – Abandoned – Inside TimeInside Time Behind the Gate: HMP Ashwell – Abandoned – Inside Time That recent institutional past gives ghost-hunt organisers a strong atmosphere to work with: cells, corridors, fencing, dereliction, memory of confinement and the afterlife of a closed public institution.
Commercial ghost-hunt pages claim voices, footsteps, shadows, moving objects, cold touches and spectral figures at Ashwell. Haunted Happenings says former staff reported unexplained activity in the abandoned prison, while another operator advertises overnight events with equipment, group experiments and guided investigation.[hauntedhappenings.co.uk]hauntedhappenings.co.ukOpen source on hauntedhappenings.co.uk.[haunted-houses.co.uk]haunted-houses.co.ukOpen source on haunted-houses.co.uk.
Those claims should be understood as event marketing and participant folklore rather than settled evidence. Still, Ashwell matters to Rutland’s haunted geography because it shows how ghost stories continue to form around newer buildings, not only medieval churches and manor houses. In a small county, a closed prison can become a modern ruin quickly: a place where documented disorder, empty architecture and controlled public access create the conditions for eerie storytelling.
Churches, rectories and religious unease
Rutland’s church hauntings are especially revealing because the county’s built heritage is rich in parish churches. Rutland County Council points to ancient churches as part of the county’s historic landscape, and this ecclesiastical setting gives many local stories their tone: not horror in the modern cinematic sense, but unease around death, burial, conscience, prayer and local authority.[Rutland County Council]rutland.gov.ukRutland County Council Local history and heritage | Rutland County CouncilRutland County Council Local history and heritage | Rutland County Council
At Tickencote, recent ghostly writing is tied to St Peter’s Church. Oakham Nub News reported in 2025 that local psychic author Diana Mary Rose had written about ghostly encounters at Tickencote Church, noting that the church was mostly rebuilt in 1792 but retains areas dating back to the Norman period and had passed into the care of the Churches Conservation Trust in 2019 before reopening to visitors in 2022.[Oakham Nub News]oakham.nub.newsOpen source on nub.news. The Churches Conservation Trust describes St Peter’s as first constructed around 1150, with its huge Norman arch and rare sexpartite vaulted chancel ceiling preserved and rebuilt piece by piece.[Churches Conservation Trust]visitchurches.org.ukst peters church tickencotest peters church tickencote
That architectural context matters more than the claim itself. Tickencote’s ghostly appeal comes from its survival: a partly Norman sacred space, altered in the Georgian period, conserved in the present and visited by people already primed to read old stone as memory. The recent account is personal and explicitly psychic, so readers should not treat it as a historical haunting in the same way as a dated newspaper case. It is better understood as a contemporary spiritual response to a very old building.
Stoke Dry has a darker church legend. The Paranormal Database records a “Hungry Witch” around the church: a woman supposedly held against her will, denied food and water, and said to haunt the place where she died.[Paranormal Database]paranormaldatabase.comParanormal Database The Paranormal DatabaseParanormal Database The Paranormal Database A separate church-crawling source treats the wider Stoke Dry tradition cautiously, noting the local Gunpowder Plot association with Sir Everard Digby and adding that the legend of the plot being hatched in the porch room is disputed.[Churchcrawling]robschurches.comstoke dry rutlandstoke dry rutland The ghost story and the treason story both use the same kind of space: a small, enclosed, morally charged room above or near a church entrance.
Pilton’s former rectory adds another clerical note: a grey priestly ghost was said to gaze from a window and bang to remind people of his presence.[Paranormal Database]paranormaldatabase.comParanormal Database The Paranormal DatabaseParanormal Database The Paranormal Database This is a compact but recognisable rectory haunting, built around repetition rather than drama: a window, a figure, a knock, a reminder that the house has not fully released its former religious occupant.
Oakham Castle and Oakham School: history is stronger than haunting
Oakham Castle is central to Rutland’s heritage, but it is not the county’s strongest ghost site. Its power lies in visible history rather than a major apparition tradition. The official Oakham Castle site says the surviving Great Hall was built between 1180 and 1190 and is famed for more than 230 ceremonial horseshoes, with the oldest surviving example given by Edward IV in 1470.[Oakham Castle]oakhamcastle.orgOpen source on oakhamcastle.org.[Oakham Castle]oakhamcastle.orgOpen source on oakhamcastle.org.
That does not make Oakham irrelevant to haunted Rutland. Quite the opposite: it anchors the county’s atmosphere. A Norman hall, courts, banquets, aristocratic horseshoes and centuries of civic ritual provide the mental landscape in which ghost walks and Halloween events make sense. Oakham Nub News reported a 2022 family spooky walking tour departing from Oakham Castle, focused on Oakham’s ghosts, ghouls and long-buried secrets.[Oakham Nub News]oakham.nub.newsOpen source on nub.news.
Oakham School has a more specific paranormal association through Matthew Manning, who claimed in his book The Link that a poltergeist outbreak centred on him there around 1971, involving moving bunk beds and showers of stones or concrete.[Paranormal Database]paranormaldatabase.comParanormal Database The Paranormal DatabaseParanormal Database The Paranormal Database This is a named modern claim rather than an old county legend, and it belongs as much to the 1970s interest in psychical phenomena as to Rutland folklore. Without independent assessment in the local sources cited here, it should be presented as Manning’s claim, not as a verified school haunting.
How credible are Rutland’s haunted traditions?
Rutland’s ghost stories are uneven, which is normal for county folklore. A sensible reader can sort them into three broad types.
The first group contains dated or historically framed reports, such as Edith Weston’s 1896 knocking case and the Langham House story preserved in an early twentieth-century county historical record. These are valuable because they have time, place and narrative detail, even when the explanation remains uncertain.[Paranormal Database]paranormaldatabase.comParanormal Database The Paranormal DatabaseParanormal Database The Paranormal Database[langhaminrutland.org.uk]langhaminrutland.org.uklangham ghostlangham ghost
The second group contains travelling legends attached to Rutland places. Exton Hall’s Mistletoe Bough belongs here. It is culturally important, atmospheric and locally meaningful, but its wider literary history makes it much less likely to be a straightforward record of one Rutland tragedy.[Wikipedia]WikipediaLegend of the Mistletoe BoughLegend of the Mistletoe Bough
The third group contains modern experience-writing and commercial ghost tourism, including Tickencote psychic accounts and Ashwell Prison ghost hunts. These are part of the living folklore of Rutland, but their evidence is shaped by personal belief, event marketing and the expectations of visitors.[Oakham Nub News]oakham.nub.newsOpen source on nub.news.[haunted-houses.co.uk]haunted-houses.co.ukOpen source on haunted-houses.co.uk.
The most honest conclusion is not that Rutland is either “full of ghosts” or “not haunted”. It is that Rutland has a small, distinctive haunted tradition rooted in houses, halls, churches, inns and institutional remains. Its best stories are intimate rather than spectacular: a figure by a Langham flower bed, knocks in an Edith Weston house, a bride imagined in an Exton chest, a hunched shape moving towards a Belmesthorpe well, a former prison corridor repurposed for night-time investigation. In Rutland, the uncanny usually appears close to the parish, the household and the memory of people who once belonged to a place.
Amazon book picks
Further Reading
Books and field guides related to Where Does Rutland Hide Its Ghosts?. Use these as the next step if you want deeper reading beyond the article.
The Mammoth Book of Haunted House Stories
First published 2000. Subjects: ghost stories, haunted house stories, ghost story anthology, Ghost stories.
The Penguin Guide to the Superstitions of Britain and Ireland
First published 2006. Subjects: Nonfiction, Reference, Superstition, Dictionaries, History.
eBay marketplace picks
Marketplace Samples
Live-tested eBay searches with available results related to this page.
Endnotes
1.
Source: commons.wikimedia.org
Title: File:England Historic Counties Rutland map.svg
Link:https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File%3AEngland_Historic_Counties_Rutland_map.svg
2.
Source: Wikipedia
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rutland
3.
Source: Wikipedia
Title: Legend of the Mistletoe Bough
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legend_of_the_Mistletoe_Bough
4.
Source: langhaminrutland.org.uk
Title: [langham ghost]({{ ‘langham-ghost/’ | relative_url }})
Link:https://www.langhaminrutland.org.uk/pdftemp/langham_ghost.pdf
5.
Source: hauntedhappenings.co.uk
Link:https://www.hauntedhappenings.co.uk/ashwell-prison/
6.
Source: haunted-houses.co.uk
Link:https://www.haunted-houses.co.uk/ghost-hunt/ashwell-prison/
7.
Source: oakham.nub.news
Link:https://oakham.nub.news/news/local-news/oakham-based-psychic-author-writes-about-her-experience-with-ghosts-at-tickencote-church-in-rutland-254212
8.
Source: oakham.nub.news
Link:https://oakham.nub.news/news/local-features/oakham-in-history-find-out-about-oakhams-ghosts-on-a-spooky-walking-tour-154018
9.
Source: Wikipedia
Title: Rutland County Council
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rutland_County_Council
10.
Source: Wikipedia
Link:https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datei%3ABritish_Isles_map_showing_UK%2C_Republic_of_Ireland%2C_and_historic_counties.svg
11.
Source: Wikipedia
Title: History of Rutland
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Rutland
12.
Source: Wikipedia
Title: HM Prison Ashwell
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HM_Prison_Ashwell
13.
Source: Wikipedia
Title: Oakham Castle
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oakham_Castle
14.
Source: Wikipedia
Title: St Peter’s Church, Tickencote
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St_Peter%27s_Church%2C_Tickencote
15.
Source: Wikipedia
Title: Everard Digby
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Everard_Digby
16.
Source: oakham.nub.news
Title: ghost hunters coming to rutland country hall
Link:https://oakham.nub.news/news/local-news/ghost-hunters-coming-to-rutland-country-hall
17.
Source: haunted-houses.co.uk
Title: Ashwell Prison Ghost Hunt
Link:https://www.haunted-houses.co.uk/event/ashwell-prison-ghost-hunt-saturday-4th-july-2026/
18.
Source: rutland.gov.uk
Title: Rutland County Council Local history and heritage | Rutland County Council
Link:https://www.rutland.gov.uk/libraries-culture-leisure/local-history-heritage
19.
Source: paranormaldatabase.com
Title: Paranormal Database The Paranormal Database
Link:https://www.paranormaldatabase.com/Rutland/rutlanddata.php
20.
Source: rutlandheritageandarts.wordpress.com
Title: Rutland Heritage and Arts Exton
Link:https://rutlandheritageandarts.wordpress.com/2015/05/13/exton/
21.
Source: insidetime.org
Title: Inside Time Behind the Gate: HMP Ashwell – Abandoned – Inside Time
Link:https://insidetime.org/jailbreak/behind-the-gate-hmp-ashwell-abandoned/
22.
Source: visitchurches.org.uk
Title: st peters church tickencote
Link:https://www.visitchurches.org.uk/visit/our-churches/st-peters-church-tickencote
23.
Source: robschurches.com
Title: stoke dry rutland
Link:https://www.robschurches.com/stoke-dry-rutland
24.
Source: oakhamcastle.org
Link:https://www.oakhamcastle.org/
25.
Source: oakhamcastle.org
Link:https://www.oakhamcastle.org/about/
26.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/RealCounties/photos/the-county-of-rutland-is-a-small-landlocked-shire-of-the-midlandsrutland-is-the-/902082232075345/
27.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/groups/churchcrawling/posts/2256178114904037/
28.
Source: greatenglishchurches.co.uk
Link:https://www.greatenglishchurches.co.uk/html/tickencote.html
29.
Source: paranormaldatabase.com
Link:https://www.paranormaldatabase.com/leicestershire/leicdata.php
30.
Source: paranormaldatabase.com
Link:https://www.paranormaldatabase.com/hotspots/Leicester.php
31.
Source: wikishire.co.uk
Link:https://wikishire.co.uk/wiki/Rutland
32.
Source: youtube.com
Title: The Mistletoe Bough
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XLa5t44f9Mg
33.
Source: rutlandhighsheriff.com
Link:https://rutlandhighsheriff.com/county/
34.
Source: rickisblogcabin.wordpress.com
Title: top 10 haunted castle hotels in europe
Link:https://rickisblogcabin.wordpress.com/2017/10/15/top-10-haunted-castle-hotels-in-europe/
35.
Source: munairmak.wordpress.com
Title: legend of the mistletoe bough
Link:https://munairmak.wordpress.com/2015/04/08/legend-of-the-mistletoe-bough/
36.
Source: mistletoematters.wordpress.com
Title: urban mythletoe the story of the mistletoe bride
Link:https://mistletoematters.wordpress.com/2012/12/04/urban-mythletoe-the-story-of-the-mistletoe-bride/
37.
Source: apetcher.wordpress.com
Title: the gunpowder plot a mad witch and the dam busters
Link:https://apetcher.wordpress.com/2023/09/30/the-gunpowder-plot-a-mad-witch-and-the-dam-busters/
38.
Source: johneckersley.wordpress.com
Title: nobles horseshoes
Link:https://johneckersley.wordpress.com/tales/nobles-horseshoes/
39.
Source: paranormaleyeuk.co.uk
Title: Ashwell Prison Ghost Hunts
Link:https://www.paranormaleyeuk.co.uk/peuk1/ashwell-prison-ghost-hunt
40.
Source: museumsuk.com
Title: Oakham Castle
Link:https://museumsuk.com/museums/oakham/oakham-castle.html
41.
Source: 1620shouse.org.uk
Link:https://1620shouse.org.uk/history/
42.
Source: le.ac.uk
Link:https://le.ac.uk/news/2023/october/halloween
43.
Source: burtoncotesprestwold-pc.gov.uk
Title: gunpowder treason
Link:https://www.burtoncotesprestwold-pc.gov.uk/gunpowder-treason
44.
Source: talesfromthefen.co.uk
Title: the mistletoe bough
Link:https://www.talesfromthefen.co.uk/blog/the-mistletoe-bough
45.
Source: peterboroughchurches.com
Link:https://www.peterboroughchurches.com/tickencote
46.
Source: warwickshire.gov.uk
Link:https://www.warwickshire.gov.uk/visit/homepage/28/gunpowder-treason-and-pplot
Additional References
47.
Source: youtube.com
Title: We Explore The HAUNTED ASHWELL PRISON | What was Making all that Noise!
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T3KYimusFOE
Source snippet
HAUNTED Prison that Locals FEAR! ft. @theouijabrothers...
48.
Source: youtube.com
Title: HAUNTED Prison that Locals FEAR! ft. @theouijabrothers
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hx62jIvZh3k
Source snippet
The Mistletoe Bough by Thomas Haynes Bayly - Lost Christmas Carols...
49.
Source: youtube.com
Title: HALLOWEEN Special: GHOSTS of Ashwell Prison
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1joQI8jLbeo
Source snippet
We Explore The HAUNTED ASHWELL PRISON | What was Making all that Noise...
50.
Source: parkdeanresorts.co.uk
Link:https://www.parkdeanresorts.co.uk/discover-more/discover/most-haunted-places-in-england/
51.
Source: gazetteer.org.uk
Link:https://gazetteer.org.uk/place/Belmesthorpe%2C_Rutland_3204
52.
Source: instagram.com
Link:https://www.instagram.com/p/DXhaVU8DIyF/
53.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/OakhamNubNews/posts/do-you-believe-in-ghosts-where-else-in-rutland-might-you-find-them/1435985619945809/
54.
Source: instagram.com
Link:https://www.instagram.com/p/DQGjWHHk1o0/
55.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/JerseyHeritage/posts/ghost-stories-from-the-castle-as-we-approach-the-scariest-night-of-the-year-here/1244957541004811/
56.
Source: haunted-britain.com
Link:https://www.haunted-britain.com/north-west.htm
Topic Tree
Follow this branch
Related pages 91
- Haunted Clackmannanshire
- Haunted Antrim
- Haunted Armagh
- Haunted Durham
- Haunted Londonderry
- +86 more in sidebar